Syria at a Crossroads: Scenarios in the Event of Assad’s Fall
Executive Summary
Syrian rebel advances west of Aleppo highlight the fractured state of the Assad regime, reflecting the ongoing deterioration of Bashar al-Assad’s grip on power. While recent successes by Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) and other rebel factions demonstrate the regime’s vulnerability, the potential collapse of Assad’s government could lead to devastating outcomes. Scenarios include a dangerous power vacuum, intensified sectarian violence, the proliferation of chemical weapons, and regional destabilization, underscoring the grave uncertainty Syria faces.
Analysis
The Assad regime’s reliance on external support has long been a cornerstone of its survival. The recent death of Iranian Revolutionary Guards Brigadier General Kioumars Pourhashemi in Aleppo and Hezbollah’s reallocation of resources to address domestic unrest in Lebanon reflect the fragility of Assad’s alliances. The growing isolation of the Syrian government is compounded by intensified Israeli strikes on Iranian and Hezbollah positions in Syria, further weakening the regime's ability to maintain control.
Rebel forces, led by Hayat Tahrir al-Sham and supported by some factions of the Turkey-backed Syrian National Army, have taken advantage of these fractures. Their recent offensive, "Response to the Aggression," has yielded significant territorial gains, including the capture of Base 46 and several strategic villages. These areas, previously fortified by Syrian and Iranian forces, were critical to the regime’s defensive strategy around Aleppo. The rapid collapse of these positions underscores the regime’s diminishing capacity to withstand coordinated attacks.
The potential fall of Assad's regime raises several grave scenarios for Syria and the broader region. The dissolution of centralized authority could plunge Syria into a power vacuum similar to post-2003 Iraq, leading to widespread violence and lawlessness. Sectarian divisions, already exacerbated by years of conflict, could erupt into full-scale reprisals against Alawite and Christian communities who were seen as loyal to Assad. Additionally, the proliferation of Assad’s chemical weapon stockpiles poses a severe threat, with extremist groups likely vying for control of these assets.
A prolonged conflict could also spill into neighboring countries, destabilizing Lebanon, Iraq, and Turkey. Regional powers, including Iran and Turkey, may find themselves drawn deeper into the conflict, further complicating efforts to achieve a resolution. The humanitarian toll continues to rise, with millions displaced and dependent on aid in a region already strained by decades of instability.
Despite these challenges, the rebels face their own obstacles. The lack of a unified command structure among opposition forces raises concerns about their ability to govern effectively should they succeed in toppling Assad. Fragmentation within rebel ranks could lead to infighting, undermining efforts to stabilize the country and rebuild its institutions.
Syria stands at a crossroads, with the Assad regime’s decline presenting both opportunities and risks for the country’s future. While the regime’s fall would mark the end of decades of authoritarian rule, it also risks plunging Syria into deeper chaos without a clear path toward unity and reconciliation.
Sources
